Good News: Occupy chalk protestor acquited on all counts

There’s a new tunnel under the new, expanded “bypass” near my home. The graffiti wars have begun. Not in chalk either. Lots of it pretty icky, ugly, and that sometimes gets transformed. Somebody paints something hateful. Like “fuck you.” Another person changes it to read “fuck your stuff.” On and on. Then not sure who — the city? — comes and paints over the whole thing and it starts again. Not exactly political protest, more cultural malaise, seething rage, distorted creativity, the beauty that we are, twisted into nearly unrecognizable form . . .

Very unlike the interesting, good looking protest graffiti that, at least this one time, not only gets to live on, but has gone viral, thanks to the lawsuit. Eat that, Bank of America!


chalk-crime-sceneSan Diego jury finds protester not guilty in chalk-vandalism case

July 1, 2013

by Tony Perry

latimes.com

SAN DIEGO — A jury Monday acquitted a 40-year-old man of all charges connected with writing protest messages in chalk on the sidewalk outside branches of the Bank of America.

The case has exacerbated the already tense relationship between Mayor Bob Filner, who called the case “stupid” and a “waste of money,” and City Atty. Jan Goldsmith, who defended it as a legitimate prosecution for graffiti vandalism.

Deliberating for only a few hours, the jury apparently agreed with Filner — declaring Jeff Olson not guilty on all 13 misdemeanor counts filed by Goldsmith’s office.

Olson, who said he was inspired by the Occupy Wall Street movement, never denied writing the slogans.

One slogan said, “No thanks, big banks.” Another, “Shame on Bank of America.” And in yet another, the bank was portrayed as an octopus grabbing at cash with its tentacles.

“It’s chalk,” Filner told reporters last week in an exasperated tone. “It’s water-soluble chalk. They were political slogans.”

But courts have held that graffiti remains illegal even if it can be easily washed off, Goldsmith said.

That the Bank of America contacted the city attorney’s office to reportedly urge prosecution has become part of the dispute.

“We prosecute vandalism and theft cases regardless of who the perpetrator or victim might be,” Goldsmith said. “We don’t decide, for example, based upon whether we like or dislike banks. That would be wrong under the law.”

Filner’s background may be instructive. He was a civil rights activist in the 1960s, a Freedom Rider in the Deep South, arrested and jailed in Mississippi. He is often distrustful of entrenched authority and large corporations.Earlier this year, Filner appeared as a defense witness in the city attorney’s prosecution of a pro-seal activist for removing a sign at the Children’s Pool beach in La Jolla. The activist pleaded guilty.

As the chalk case approached trial, Filner sent a memo to Goldsmith calling it “an abuse of power that infringes on [the] 1st Amendment.”

At trial, however, Judge Howard Shore said Olson’s lawyer could not invoke the 1st Amendment as a defense.

As the dispute flared between the Democratic mayor and Republican city attorney, Shore imposed a gag order on all parties. The mayor, however, would not be gagged.

“This is a nonsense prosecution and I will continue to say that,” Filner said Friday.

_____

Here’s one version of the original story.

California chalk protester hit with gag order

for protesting Bank of America!

Jeff Olson, Chalk Activist Facing 13 years in jail for protesting Bank of America

California chalk protester hit with gag order

June 28, 2013

Reuters / Darryl Webb via americankabuki

A California man facing more than a decade in prison for writing with chalk on public sidewalks has been told he’s barred from discussing the details of his controversial case outside of court.

Judge Howard Shore issued a gag-order in a San Diego, California courtroom this week against Jeff Olson, a 40-year-old activist that used washable children’s chalk to scribble anti-bank slogans in public space last year.

According to the San Diego Reader, the gag-order issued on Friday also applies to witnesses, members of the jury and potentially others, a measure that Truth-Out editor Mark Karlin said is “unprecedented” for a misdemeanor trial.

Olson has been charged with 13 misdemeanor counts of vandalism for chalking slogans such as “No Thanks, Big Banks” and “Shame on Bank of America” on the sidewalks outside of branches in the San Diego area throughout 2012. Now as the criminal trial against him wages on in Southern California, the defendant and anyone remotely involved in the case are reportedly muzzled by a ban that could bring media coverage of the case to a grinding halt.

The Reader reports that Judge Shore issued the gag-order during Friday’s hearing after expressing his discontent with comments Olson made about his potential sentencing. According to the charge sheet filed by the city of San Diego, Olson could be subjected to $13,000 in fines and a maximum of 13 years in prison if convicted, prompting the defendant to make a myriad of remarks in recent weeks, including one to the U-T San Diego newspaper that called the prosecution, “an unconstitutional overreach and a total waste of taxpayer money.”

Commenting to reporters on Friday, Judge Shore said a decade behind bars was “not going to happen” and insisted he “would be surprised if it ever happened to any defendant with no criminal record.”

Shortly after those remarks, OIson read a note to the court that said in part, “This morning Judge Shore issued a gag order prohibiting all counsel and parties from commenting or expressing opinions on the case. All I am permitted to say is that I disagree.”

As Karlin notes, Judge Shore’s issuing of the gag-order came just days after Olson told reporters, “My chalk drawings are clearly free speech and protected by the First Amendment.”

Speaking to CBS News previously, Olson defended his act of protest:

“Always on city sidewalks, washable chalk, never crude messages, never vulgar, clearly topical,” he said.

Prosecutors in San Diego aren’t amused with his work, however, and have discounted Olson’s assertion that he was engaging in an act of free speech. Judge Shore said earlier in the week that Olson’s attorney is prohibited from “mentioning the First Amendment, free speech, free expression, public forum, expressive conduct or political speech during the trial,” but the issuing of a gag-order now limits much more than what was already decided.

Olson said that at the heart of his case is not the issue of vandalism, but an infringement on the right to free speech. He has accused San Diego City Attorney Jan Goldsmith of trying to stop him from talking because he has raked in heavy donations from the banks in the past, and is now reported to be eyeing a bid at the mayor’s role in 2016.

“Jan Goldsmith has received campaign contributions from Bank Americorp and Merrill Lynch. I think this is mostly about Goldsmith for Mayor 2016,” Olson told San Diego 6 News.

“If I had drawn a little girl’s hopscotch squares on the street, we wouldn’t be here today,” the activist added to KGTV News.

Bob Filner, the mayor of San Diego, issued a statement last week calling for the city to drop their case against Olson.

“This young man is being persecuted for thirteen counts of vandalism stemming from an expression of political protest that involved washable children’s chalk on a City sidewalk,” Filner wrote. “It is alleged that he has no previous criminal record. If these assertions are correct, I believe this is a misuse and waste of taxpayer money. It could also be characterized as an abuse of power that infringes on First Amendment particularly when it is arbitrarily applied to some, but not all, similar speech.”

Goldsmith responded to the mayor’s claims by defending the prosecution, saying, “We prosecute vandalism and theft cases regardless of who the perpetrator or victim might be.”

“We don’t decide, for example, based upon whether we like or dislike banks,” Goldsmith told the U-T San Diego website. “That would be wrong under the law and such a practice by law enforcement would change our society in very damaging ways.”

“I’m am not going out on a limb to say that this is outrageous,” quipped Olson.


This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Good News: Occupy chalk protestor acquited on all counts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *